The True Cost of DIY Business Intelligence for NHS Workforces
27 June 2022
Many of us have successfully taken on DIY projects at home, and been happy with the results – maybe it isn’t quite as good as a professional would have done, but good enough considering you didn’t have to pay anyone else. But you probably wouldn’t consider building a whole house from the ground up… and then when circumstances or requirements change, also build the extension yourself. You’d seek the help of a builder with the right tools, capacity, industry knowledge and assurance. That’s how we feel about People Analytics.
There are many tools out there to help you with People Analytics, from spreadsheets to market-leading Business Intelligence solutions – let’s explore these two options available a little further:
As this presents, to perform true, sustainable People Analytics, you need the right tools for the job, just as you would if building a house – you can’t dig foundations with only a spade!
So, as useful as spreadsheets are, I think that most HR leaders would agree that this is not a sustainable or scalable tool to take People Analytics forward, particularly for the NHS.
Business Intelligence solutions will give an organisation the right tools, but now, let’s look at the in-depth costs for implementing and using BI – both the obvious and the not-so-obvious:
- Software Costs: Whilst MS Excel incurs no additional software costs, BI solutions are usually quite expensive. Where cost is based on the number of licences needed, the bill can run to many thousands of pounds depending on the size of the organisation. In addition, an organisation may require a Data Warehouse to store data – which can also be expensive to implement and maintain.
- Training Costs: Most people are familiar with Excel, although may need some training to utilise VBA and macros. However, the resources and time required to upskill your workforce to make a BI solution work can be significant. Not to mention, the ongoing training to stay up to date with new functions or implementing different types of analysis can also be significant. If or when a person with the required skillset leaves an organisation, the cost of replacing that person also needs to be considered – what will it cost to employ an individual with the necessary valuable skills and any additional training they will need?
- People Costs: Regardless of whether using an Excel or a BI solution, an organisation will need to invest in people to build, maintain and enhance it for a workforce’s ongoing needs. You may build a set of metrics in Excel and think that this has cost you nothing – but someone with a valuable skill set has likely worked on that alone for a significant amount of time. It is also likely that it will quickly fall out of date with future needs, particularly with the evolving landscape of NHS Workforce reporting. BI solutions will require skillsets that are expensive to come by. Assuming you would need a minimum of two Business Intelligence professionals, the true cost of a BI solution will be more than £100k per year, on top of the licensing and training costs.
- Risk: What will be the cost to the organisation if an important set of reports do not work, or you urgently need to react to a situation, such as Covid-19, and get insight? DIY solutions such as spreadsheets and BI solutions often promote single points of failure. If a person is off sick or leaves, the organisation is often found to be overly reliant on them. You could employ two people and double your costs to maintain the solution – but again, if one of these employees leaves or goes on long-term sick leave, you will still have a single point of failure again (albeit hopefully for not quite as long)
Our belief is that NHS Workforce data deserves its own dedicated analytics platform that does not require specific experts or specialists… a Pure Play approach.
What is Pure Play People Analytics?
• The focus is purely on Workforce data, no competing organisational priorities
• Simple for all levels of users, and created for the non-technical user
• Choose from a suite of pre-built Workforce Metrics, Statistical Models and Reporting
• Enables multi-dimensional data discovery
• Powerful segmentation abilities, to get to the most relevant data quickly and cut through the noise
• Aggregate and drill down into individual records for granular detail
• Algorithms driving calcs and people analytics with powerful visualisations and data discovery
• Role-based user access, all within a GDPR-compliant environment
• Cloud-based with lower total cost of ownership
• Faster deployment to get to HR value as quickly as possible
• Minimised risk of implementation failure
The unique advantage of the NHS is that the priorities are very similar in most organisations, and for us, this is comparable to building a whole street of the same houses and then applying unique finishing touches at the end for each consumer.
There are standard NHS metric definitions and report packs available, and as many NHS organisations use a suite of the same Workforce solutions to capture data, this has enabled us to quickly deploy an 80/20 standard “out of the box build” within weeks of IG approval.
We work with NHS organisations to adapt and create content that is specific to their unique requirements, and then work with them to release, review, and reiterate through an adoption period – where we look to take on more data sets and engage with a wide range of user personas throughout the organisation, from Senior Management to Ward Managers.
To introduce People Analytics within an organisation, it is essential that the organisation is sitting on good foundations to make the most of the insights – just like building a house. Please see our whitepaper Building the foundations for People Analytics for more on this topic.
To discuss our People Analytics solution and how it can benefit your organisation, please get in touch at [email protected]
Carl Gould, Technical Consultant